Dying of Thirst Rules for PbtA Systems

Apr 17, 2025

The human body requires roughly 1 liter of water a day to survive. The average person can survive three to five days without water. Our heroes, of course, are not average people, but we don’t want to throw all verisimilitude out the window. Therefore I propose for your consideration:

DYING OF THIRST RULES

For each day you go without food and water, you suffer 1 harm. Your mouth is dry and your eyes are sunken.

When you have gone three full days without food and water, you begin dying of thirst. You have stopped urinating. You are lethargic and irritable. Roll +hard every day when you wake up. On a 10+ you keep it together by sheer will. On a 7-9, choose one Thirst Symptom and the MC holds it to be played as the next Hard Move if you fail another roll within the next 24 hours.

When you’ve gone five full days without food and water, you really don’t feel like moving. All stats except weird are -1. Continue to roll +hard every day when you wake up, but the results are different now: On a 10+ you keep it together by sheer will. On a 7-9, choose one Thirst Symptom and the MC will hold it to be played at any time within the next 24 hours. On a fail, in addition to the resulting Hard Move, the MC will choose a Thirst Symptom and hold it to be played at any time within the next 24 hours.

THIRST SYMPTOMS:
Vomiting
Diarrhea
Fainting
Dizziness
Minor Heart Attack

REHYDRATION:
Consumption of 1 liter of water will remove all harm and symptoms caused by thirst. This takes only a few minutes.

FOOD BUT NO WATER

Water is extracted from food during digestion, so if the character is eating food but not getting water, the rules are different:

For every 48 hours you get food but no water, you suffer 1 harm.

When you have gone six full days in this condition, you are lethargic and irritable. Roll +hard every day when you wake up. On a 10+ you keep it together by sheer will. On a 7-9, choose one symptom and the MC holds it to be played as the next Hard Move if you fail another roll within the next 24 hours.

When you’ve gone ten full days in this condition, you really don’t feel like moving. All stats except weird are -1. Roll +hard every day when you wake up. On a 10+ you keep it together by sheer will. On a 7-9, choose one symptom and the MC will hold it to be played at any time within the next 24 hours. On a fail, in addition to the resulting Hard Move, the MC will choose a symptom and hold it to be played at any time within the next 24 hours.

Explore More Insights

Roleplaying Games – Where’s the Art?

Roleplaying Games – Where’s the Art?

Over at Coming Out of the Basement, Jack Stephenson-Carr is engaging in an in-depth analysis of the question (and the assumptions behind the question): "Are Roleplaying Games Art?" Here's my take on it. Certainly they are, if they convey meaning. But they're not...

read more

Stat Conversion – 1d100 to Powered by the Apocalypse

If you're interested in running oldschool characters in a PbtA system, or using PbtA moves in a d100-based game, you need a way to convert stats and moves between the two systems. Here is my 1d100 to PbtA Stats conversion table... 1d100 AW10 AW7 01-03 = -2 = -5 04-09...

read more